German top court overturns double jeopardy reform

Germany's Federal Constitutional Court low struck down a 2021 judicial reform on Tuesday, ruling that individuals in cases of murder and war crimes cannot be tried again for the same offense.

Judges ruled that the reform of the Code of Criminal Procedure passed in December 2021 was unconstitutional, and thus null and void.

What is behind the case?

The reform was passed by the Bundestag, the lower house of parliament, under Angela Merkel's chancellorship. It limited retrials to crimes such as murder, genocide, and war crimes, which are not subject to a statute of limitations.

The complaint was brought by a man who was found not guilty in 1981 for the rape and murder of a 17-year-old girl in the northwestern state of Lower Saxony. The man was initially sentenced to life in prison but appealed and was acquitted at a retrial for lack of evidence.

A second trial against the suspect was initiated in 2022 after he was charged again on the basis of new DNA evidence.

What did the court say about the ruling?

Six judges at the court voted in favor of the ruling, while two voted against it.

Presiding judge Doris König said that Germany's constitution, known as the Basic Law, prohibits multiple punishments and prosecutions in its Article 103.

"This protects not only persons who have already been convicted once, but also persons who have been acquitted from renewed criminal proceedings," she said.

She said that the right not be tried again for the same crime was "absolute"  under the constitution, adding that it left "no room for maneuver even if it turns out in retrospect that the verdict was incorrect."

The court also found that the indictment violated a ban on applying the law retroactively.

sdi/rc (Reuters, dpa)

While you're here: Every Tuesday, DW editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter Berlin Briefing.